Personal tools

How were you unlucky enough to be born in China?

From China Digital Space

Revision as of 19:07, 29 September 2016 by Anne (talk | contribs)
Jump to: navigation, search

Shéi jiào nǐ búxìng shēng zài Zhōngguó le? 谁叫你不幸生在中国了?

He Zuoxiu and his infamous question. (Source: NetEase Luntan)

Question posed to a reporter by physicist and "crusader against unscientific thinking" He Zuoxiu, He Zuoxiu; rhetorical question for Chinese citizens hurt by corruption in the name of progress.

He Zuoxiu, a member of the Chinese Academy of Science, advocated for former president Hu Jintao's concept of a "[[Use the Internet scientifically|scientific outlook on development]" (kēxué fāzhǎn guān 科学发展观). In a 2005 interview with a reporter for Southern People's Weekly, He was asked about deaths in coal mines. The reporter offered that more than o100 people die every day in China's coal mines. He countered that a much greater number died in car accidents. When pressed by as to whether the coal mine deaths were the avoidable results of government corruption, He denied this and claimed instead that the deaths were necessary byproducts of poverty. He shot back at the reporter, "How were you so unfortunate as to be born in China?" (literally "Who told you to be born unluckily in China?"), adding, "In the process of development some sacrifices are unavoidable."

For many netizens, He's excoriation of the reporter symbolizes the emotional detachment with which the government pursues economic growth, the logical but soulless endpoint of "scientific development."

This retort to scientific development has remained in currency after Hu Jintao left office. For instance "How were you unlucky enough to be born in China?" has appeared as a sad comment on Liu Lingli, a young teacher who was fired for "absenteeism" while she was being treated for cancer. She passed away in August 2016.

China Digital Space Related Links