In yet another blow for book lovers and free thinkers in Hong Kong, national security police raided two independent bookstores (Have a Nice Stay and Greenfield, respectively) and arrested five individuals on suspicion of selling allegedly seditious publications, an offence punishable with up to seven years in prison under Hong Kong’s homegrown national security law (NSL). Three of those arrested have since been released on bail, while the status of the other two remains unclear. The raids and arrests took place on Wednesday, against the backdrop of Hong Kong’s annual international book fair. They also produced an iconic image, circulated widely on social media, of a woman with her hands cuffed behind her back, wearing a t-shirt declaring “I am a bookstore clerk,” and holding her head high as she is escorted into a police car.
At the Associated Press, Kanis Leung reported on this latest salvo in Hong Kong’s long-running crackdown on independent booksellers:
Videos and photos from multiple media outlets showed officers wearing vests marked with “Police” seizing boxes from the building housing Have A Nice Stay, a bookshop founded by former journalists. A bookseller was seen being taken away.
A few streets away a similar scene played out, with boxes taken from the building housing Greenfield Book Store, according to a video by online news outlet The Collective.
Police later said they raided two stores in Mong Kok district, without identifying them. They arrested two men and three women on suspicion of breaching the 2024 national security law, according to their statement.
This is the third round of arrests linked to independent bookstores after similar operations in March and June that were widely seen as stifling dissent in the Asian financial hub. [Source]
The following day, Hong Kong Secretary for Security Chris Tang spoke about the arrests, claiming that “the law is clear” and that booksellers are legally obligated to vet the titles they sell to weed out potentially seditious or harmful works. Just like “merchants selling food have to make sure their food won’t make people sick, that they are not selling poison [or] breaking the law,” Tang told reporters in Cantonese, “I believe booksellers have the same responsibility.” At the same time, the security chief declined to provide a list of banned books, raising concerns over what books would be considered seditious and exactly where the red lines lie. In 2022, Hong Kong authorities cited security reasons for their refusal to answer a legislator’s question about which books had been removed from public libraries under the National Security Law.
Many journalists and publishers have strenuously objected to Hong Kong authorities’ vague definition of “seditious” content and consistent refusal to specify which titles are actually banned. CDT Chinese editors recently archived “How Chris Tang Shattered Xi Jinping’s Dream,” a satirical article by former Apple Daily columnist Fung Hei-kin. Fung discusses how the Hong Kong bookstore raids reverberated in Taiwan, where the book “Let Only Red Flowers Bloom: Identity and Belonging in Xi Jinping’s China,” by National Public Radio journalist Emily Feng, shot to the top of the bestseller lists after being identified by Hong Kong authorities as one of the allegedly seditious works. The author jocularly suggests that Security Chief Tang’s targeting of the booksellers has only served to fuel anti-China sentiment in Taiwan, thus “shattering Xi Jinping’s dream” of unifying Taiwan and the PRC.
The recent raids and arrests were condemned by a number of international journalism, publishing, and rights organizations. The Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) issued a statement the following day calling “on Hong Kong authorities to immediately release freelance journalists and booksellers Sum Wan-wah and Mandy Lau [the pair have since been released] and end their escalating crackdown on independent publishing in the city, following the second such incident in less than a month.” More detail from the CPJ statement:
Have A Nice Stay’s owners include former reporters from the now-shuttered news outlet Stand News, according to Pulse HK News. One of the bookstore’s missions, its website says, is to promote journalism and literary reportage. In 2023, the bookstore also launched the online magazine Leave Blank to “reclaim the identity of being journalists.”
“Using national security legislation to go after another bookstore run by journalists is an attack on press freedom and independent publishing in the city,” said CPJ Asia-Pacific Director Beh Lih Yi. “Hong Kong authorities must release journalists Sum Wan-wah and Mandy Lau and stop persecuting independent publishers.”
Police have accused the five of selling and displaying publications that incited hatred against the Hong Kong government, the judiciary, and law enforcement agencies. […] Among the seized books was “Let Only Red Flowers Bloom: Identity and Belonging in Xi Jinping’s China,” by National Public Radio journalist Emily Feng, according to news reports. [Source]
The targeting of the five booksellers and their wares coincided with Hong Kong’s annual Book Fair, which has come under increased political and censorship pressure in recent years, particularly since the introduction of the National Security Law. Hong Kong Free Press reported on the book fair, the recent raids, and the targeting of two other bookstores just last month:
The Hong Kong Trade Development Council (HKTDC) event took place in the backdrop of national security raids and arrests at two independent bookstores, while two others were reportedly banned from taking part in the fair.
On Wednesday, the first day of the fair, police searched Have a Nice Stay and Greenfield and arrested five operators […] for alleged sedition.
Last month, local media reported that bookstores Elmbook and Luck Win were disqualified by the fair’s organisers despite obtaining prior approval to participate.
The two long-running bookshops had been frequent exhibitors at the book fair. […] Elmbook later announced the decision to shut down its 29-year-old physical store in Mong Kok and is holding a clearance sale. [Source]
Only one day before its premises were raided by police, Have a Nice Stay had already announced it would be closing by the end of the summer due to financial constraints and the difficulty of navigating constantly shifting “red lines.” Alexandra Stevenson at The New York Times provided more background about the impending closure:
Have A Nice Stay was founded and run by local journalists, some of whom previously worked for Stand News, an independent online publication that was shut down in 2021 after the police raided it. Earlier this week, Have a Nice Stay announced it would cease operations on Aug. 30, citing a number of factors including financial issues and “social climate.”
“Looking at the overall economic situation in Hong Kong, we can only take a pessimistic view: it is becoming increasingly difficult to carry on,” read a notice posted on Instagram.
“Our capacity is limited,” the note said, adding that employees could not possibly read and review every book, “let alone determine which ones might be deemed ‘problematic’.” [Source]



