This post from WeChat account 百里曾游 Bǎilǐ Céngyóu ("100 Li Once Traveled"), deleted at the source but archived at CDT Chinese, describes the gauntlet of security checks, ID-card scans, pat-downs, bag-checks, book-checks, hem-lifts, and shoe-squeezes involved in visiting Zhengyangmen, also known as Qianmen, the towering gate at the southern edge of Beijing’s Tiananmen Square. The tone is matter-of-fact and without rancor. There is no overt criticism of the security measures or call for their relaxation or removal, still less any reference to politically sensitive episodes in the Square’s history. The post simply describes what happened, and advises visitors to avoid the area, particularly during the hot, crowded summer.

Nevertheless, the notice that has replaced it online says that "this content cannot be viewed due to rule violations. Following relevant complaints, it was found to violate the Cybersecurity Law of the People’s Republic of China." Automated keyword scanning may also have played a role: see other recent translations for more on collateral damage from this approach, and efforts by users to evade it.

Now that Zhengyangmen is open to the public, I felt compelled to make the obligatory visit to Tiananmen Square again.

I was already a bit apprehensive about the security checks after my parents’ trip to Beijing last year, when they’d decided to visit Mao’s mausoleum.

This time happened to coincide with the peak of the summer break. The heat was stifling, and it seemed like things would be even worse than before.

An entrance to Qianmen subway station, with the gate in the background

My goal, Zhengyangmen, is by Exit A of Qianmen Station on Line 2, but unfortunately, as I only realised later when I was trying to leave, that’s a one-way exit.

So after leaving through Exit C, I couldn’t just go straight across the road; I had to cross twice, through two separate underpasses.

This involves one ID-card swipe, and a security check.

They had to look through my bag at the security check, so I quickly got my things out. That day, that meant a book, a notebook for collecting tourist stamps and, because it had been raining a lot, an umbrella. That was about it.

I was extremely cooperative, hoping they’d finish up and let me through as quickly as possible, and of course that’s what happened.

A covered security checkpoint near Zhengyangmen, with the gate in the background

I could see Zhengyangmen ahead of me on the right and, wanting to get inside quickly, I rushed forward without thinking.

The security checker must have sensed my impatience, because they drawled said, "No point in hurrying, there’s more security up ahead."

The gate viewed from across the street, with a security awning, road signs, cameras, and street lights in the foreground

With hindsight, that first security check was just a canapé before the banquet.

As I crossed the intersection of Qianmen West and East Avenues and turned north onto West Guangchang Road, the crowds became denser.

At this point, Zhengyangmen was directly to my east. I was about to start lining up in that direction when I was courteously informed that that was the line for the group security check, and I needed to keep going.

Visitors line up for security checks. An awning is set up to one side, and a police van is parked to the other. There are trees in the background. Several people in the line are holding up parasols.

So I kept heading north. The crowd had slowed to a crawl, and started to divide again into streams: those with bags, and without.

Those without bags moved on a bit quicker, while those of us with bags continued to wait.

Visitors, many holding parasols, line up between a two-storey white building and a row of trees. Tall misting fans attempt to provide some relief from the heat.

By now, the sun was beating down on us mercilessly, and a lot of people were using parasols. Some were chatting about other places they’d visited over the past few days.

The Numismatic Museum was to the left, the building a fairly impressive sight from that angle. To the right was the mausoleum, looking solemn and dignified as always.

The clock tower of the China Numismatic Museum.

By then, we’d been kept waiting so long and had grown so impatient that it was hard to appreciate the sights.

The kids in the crowd started to get rowdy, and were variously consoled or scolded by the adults, who were suffering every bit as much as the little ones.

Kids are just more straightforward about voicing their annoyance.

The whole security line had stopped, and we had no idea what was going on up ahead.

I didn’t realize how stringent the security checks were until I actually experienced it myself. It’s even stricter than at the airport.

There are two stages to the personal security check. In the first, they pass a handheld sensor wand over your whole body and pat down your pockets, so I had to take off my sun jacket and also remove my keys, cellphone, etc. from my pockets.

I even had to take my phone out of its case so the inspector could take a look.

When you get to the second stage, an inspector of the same gender as you pats down your whole body wearing disposable gloves, and lifts the hem of your top to check for concealed items around your waist.

They poked and prodded at my shoes for a while, but fortunately they didn’t make me take them off.

Once the personal check was over, it was time for the bag inspection, and you had to take out all the contents. They looked through every page in my book, but didn’t say anything in the end.

The person inspecting the group next to me told them they couldn’t take photos with a book and certain other item—I don’t know what kind of book it was.

One reason things moved slowly was that the police were involved through the whole process: if one of the staff wasn’t sure about something, they’d call the police over, which led to more waiting.

A broader view of the China Numismatic Museum

In short, after layer after layer of checks, I got through and left the guardhouse. When I looked round, I realized there were very few others coming out, and an endless line of people still waiting.

I don’t know whether I just turned up at the busiest time, but I’d avoid wandering onto the Square without a particular reason, especially in summer. If you must go, stow your bags elsewhere beforehand.

Having said that, you should travel while you can. I miss the old days when you didn’t have to book in advance. [Chinese]

In contrast with this post’s deletion, another recently archived article takes a much more critical stance on security checks, but currently remains online. At the WeChat account 白马狗熊 Bái Mǎ Gǒuxióng ("White Horse Black Bear"), Song Jinbo notes tightening security checks at subway stations in many Chinese cities, and highlights claims that they are actually detrimental to public safety, causing potentially dangerous bottlenecks. Moreover, he expresses concern that well over 100,000 young Chinese may be wasting key years in their early 20s performing labor of dubious value, pointedly contrasting this with Marx’s calls for people’s "all-round development" and Xi’s calls for the young to "cherish the springtime of their lives" and strive for self-improvement in the national interest. Song posits that the checks endure because of financial interests in what has become a multi-billion-yuan industry, and because officials are reluctant to ever remove security measures in case subsequent events should make that look reckless, wrecking their careers. Meanwhile, taxpayers who objected to the cost, inconvenience, and ineffectiveness of the security checks would have no way to exert effective pressure against them. Song opens the piece with a 2024 case in which 14 fraud victims reportedly worked in non-existent outsourced roles on the Shanghai Metro for months, while their unauthorized presence went unnoticed. "A system that can’t even tell fake workers apart from real ones requires you every day to put your water bottle through security and your tote bag through a scanner. Consummate artistry."