The exposure of faulty brake-pedal brackets in the Maextro V800, a luxury EV manufactured by Huawei and JAC, has resulted in a wave of online censorship, deleted opinion pieces, a high-level government investigation, and what appears to be a coordinated campaign to undermine the credibility of Dongchedi (懂车帝, Dǒngchēdì), the automotive-review platform that brought the problem to light. The scandal has tested the boundaries of public criticism of vaunted national industries such as EVs, and highlighted the tendency among Chinese authorities and state media to “blame the messenger” when it comes to issues such as consumer product safety.
At Lingua Sinica, David Bandurski and Zack Chiang described the video that touched off the scandal, and the online censorship that ensued:
This month, one of China’s most popular auto-review platforms, Dongchedi (懂车帝), also known as “DCar,” put a new luxury minivan model through a tough highway test — braking hard to a full stop from a speed of 100 kilometers per hour. The results, revealed in a video posted across Chinese online platforms, were enough to terrify potential buyers. In three live tests of the model with vehicles purchased from separate production batches, the bracket mounting the brake pedal to the van’s frame snapped.
As attention to the video soared on platforms like WeChat, Douyin and Bilibili, becoming the number one search term within hours, it was the worst possible news for Anhui-based JAC Group and the Chinese tech giant Huawei, the companies behind the vehicle in question, the Maextro V800 multi-purpose electric vehicle (EV). In a statement the same day, Maextro called the test non-standard and extreme, and promised the part would be redesigned. But the damage was done. Only the daily limit on stock drops imposed under Chinese exchange rules could keep shares of JAC Group from heading to the bottom of the hill. They ended the day down 10.01 percent.
A controversy over a faulty brake pedal may seem far removed from the issue of media and censorship. But within 24 hours, the video had disappeared from Chinese platforms such as Bilibili, and several related online posts and reports had vanished too. Viewers on WeChat Video were informed the video could not be played due to an unspecified “violation.” The case prompted discussion of the benefits and limits of consumer reporting in China — a vibrant consumer society with some of the world’s strictest controls on information. [Source]
About a week later, on October 15, it was announced that the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, the Cyberspace Administration of China, and the State Administration for Market Regulation would be conducting a joint investigation into the brake-pedal safety incident. The inclusion of cyberspace authorities in a national consumer-product safety investigation fueled concerns that Dongchedi and outlets that shared the test video might become targets for raising the issue in the first place.
CDT Chinese editors have archived no fewer than 20 articles on the Maextro V800 brake-safety incident, several of which have been deleted. Main themes include automotive safety; the forced deletion of the initial test video; the manufacturer’s initial obfuscatory response; the unexplained deletion of op-eds from state-media outlet People’s Daily and a government information office in Xinjiang that expressed support for Dongchedi and concerns about vehicle safety; and concerns about the focus of the joint investigation. More recently, there has been a flurry of articles critical of what appears to be a coordinated campaign to undermine the credibility and motives of Dongchedi, one of China’s most trusted automotive-review platforms. There are also several pieces that offer counterarguments to media outlets and pundits who insist Chinese consumers need to be more tolerant and “give national industries more time” to mature.
This is not the first time that “national champion” Huawei has attempted to stifle critics or has suffered a public-relations disaster. In April 2024, three people, including a toddler, died when their Aito M7, a Huawei-backed sport utility EV, caught fire after a collision with a truck in Yuncheng, Shanxi province. There was some online censorship of footage showing bystanders attempting and failing to break the vehicle’s windows and doors in order to rescue the family. In August of this year, there was a massive backlash against Huawei’s heavy-handed attempts to force platforms to delete videos and memes of a toy bamboo cicada that Huawei felt was making fun of its corporate image. This resulted in a “Streisand effect” that brought even more negative attention and mockery upon the company, which responded with an ill-advised PR clapback that attempted to attribute the backlash against Huawei to malign “foreign forces.” Current affairs commentator Xu Peng, in an article that was later deleted, wrote, “Oh, give me a freaking break. What could that little bamboo cicada have possibly done to get lumped in with foreign forces?” Another censored piece, from blogger Xiang Dongliang, sardonically likened Huawei’s attempts to banish bamboo cicada memes from the Chinese internet to archaic “naming taboos” (避讳, bìhuì), which forbade the use of imperial or ancestral names in certain contexts. “[T]he management […] is either completely delusional, thanks to years of bootlicking by sycophantic underlings,” wrote Xiang, “or their ambition has swelled to the point that they believe their ‘extraordinary contributions’ have earned them a place in the history books. At any rate, it’s gone to their heads, because believe it or not, they’ve launched a campaign to enforce a ‘naming taboo’ across the entire internet.”
This time around, Xiang Dongliang weighed in with a now-deleted piece titled, “The Counterattacks Against Dongchedi Have Begun, and Show No Qualms About Distorting Facts.” In it, he takes the state-owned National Business Daily, or NBD (每日经济新闻, Měirì Jīngjì Xīnwén) and other media outlets to task for publishing the claim that Dongchedi voluntarily deleted the brake-pedal test video (when it was almost certainly removed under duress), a “story” that was later picked up by many other Chinese publications. (Although Xiang anonymizes NBD’s name, it is clear which publication he means, and the article is still visible on NBD’s website.) Xiang suggests that the unsubstantiated tale is part of a larger, coordinated “counterattack” designed to undermine the auto-review platform’s credibility and manipulate public opinion:
[…] Certain companies, however, are scrambling to use the technical timeout [brought about by the announcement of the joint investigation] to strike back and score points in the public opinion sphere by spinning a misleading narrative about Dongchedi somehow admitting it was in the wrong.
Most outrageously, certain media outlets are making a big show of accusing Dongchedi of proactively deleting the Maextro V800 test video, a counterattack that completely ignores the facts and distorts the truth.
The source of this information is a report published by Nameless Business Daily on October 16, under the headline “Dongchedi Takes Maextro V800 Test Video Offline, and Has Yet to Issue Any Official Comment."
I hesitate to even call the report “news,” because it is neither factual nor timely; it would be more accurate to call it a “rumor.”
First of all, Dongchedi’s video about the Maextro V800 suddenly vanished on October 9, over a week ago. At the time, this was widely reported by official media outlets and everyone on the internet was talking about it.
But for some unfathomable reason, a full week later, on October 16, a reporter and three editors from Nameless Business Daily decided to republish this bit of stale news as if it were something new.
There’s also the problem of factuality. The Nameless Business Daily headline claims that Dongchedi “took the video offline,” and makes a point of saying that the platform “has yet to issue any official comment.” The use of “took offline,” an active verb, coupled with Dongchedi’s lack of comment, gives readers the mistaken impression that Dongchedi proactively removed the video for some reason and is simply too embarrassed to admit it.
But as anyone with even a rudimentary understanding of the internet knows, Dongchedi is a commercial platform that spent millions of yuan to purchase those vehicles for testing, and the test video it released created a huge stir online. This would normally be the perfect time for Dongchedi to reap the rewards of its hard work and increase its commercial influence, so it has no motive to delete the video.
The only real possibility is that the video was forcibly “disappeared” by forces beyond Dongchedi’s control.
Fabricating a narrative that the auto-review platform voluntarily took a video offline, when in fact it was forced to delete it, is a vile distortion of the truth, and those who concoct such rumors are beyond despicable.
Even more loathsome is the reporter who had the nerve to ask Dongchedi to comment on why it had taken down the video, knowing full well that the platform could only swallow its grievances and decline to comment, and then painting its inability to respond as a tacit admission of guilt.
But if the media had bothered to ask whether or not they deleted the video, Dongchedi could have shot back: “It wasn’t us, we didn’t voluntarily take it down, stop making things up!”
Instead, after that stale and inaccurate report was published, it was picked up and reprinted verbatim by any number of official media outlets.
This is such an obvious problem that anyone from the “melon-eating” online masses could easily spot it, and I refuse to believe that so many editors at official media outlets would overlook it. There’s only one plausible explanation for why they were willing to reprint it verbatim: this is an organized counterattack designed to sway public opinion. [Chinese]
For more CDT coverage of consumer safety and consumer protection, see our translations related to the often-performative annual March 15 “Consumer Day” and 3.15 CCTV Gala, described by one internet commenter as “turn[ing] government inaction and inadequate supervision into a celebratory banquet”; food safety scandals over adulterated berries and other foodstuffs; product-quality concerns about sanitary pads; and the furor over fuel tankers transporting edible oil without washing between transports.



