The announcement that two Chinese mathematicians have won the Fields Medal, awarded every four years to outstanding mathematicians under 40, has been met with an outpouring of national pride on Chinese social media, as well as debate about the state of Chinese academia and whether there is enough domestic support and encouragement for emerging academic talent. It is the first time that two Chinese nationals have been awarded the prize. (In 1982, U.S.-based Yau Shing-Tung became the first ethnic Chinese mathematician to win the prize; Australian-born Terence Tao won in 2006.)
Wang Hong (王虹, Wáng Hóng), age 35, was born and raised in Guilin, Guangxi province. After graduating from Peking University, she earned advanced degrees in engineering (École Polytechnique) and mathematics (Paris-Sud) in France, and her doctorate in mathematics from MIT. Now a professor at NYU’s Courant Institute and the Institut des Hautes Études Scientifiques, Wang was awarded the Fields Medal for her contributions to harmonic analysis and geometric measure theory, and major advances on a number of mathematical conundrums, including her work on the three-dimensional “Kakeya conjecture” with collaborator Joshua Zahl (University of British Columbia). Wang is the first Chinese woman—and only the third woman overall—to win in the award’s 90-year history.
Deng Yu (邓煜, Dèng Yù), 37, was born in Kaifeng, Henan province, and raised in Shenzhen, Guangdong province. After two years at Peking University, he transferred to MIT for his undergraduate work, and later earned a doctorate in mathematics from Princeton. Currently a professor at the University of Chicago, Deng received the Fields Medal for his work in partial differential equations and his breakthrough on "Hilbert’s sixth problem," with University of Michigan collaborators Zaher Hani and Ma Xiao (Xiao Ma, in English).
CDT editors have archived over a dozen articles on various topics related to the Fields Medal winners. One popular topic concerned how much credit is due to Peking University (PKU), which proudly trumpeted the news of alums Wang and Deng winning the prestigious prize by putting up festive banners and projecting congratulatory messages onto the campus’ famed Boya Pagoda. PKU’s official WeChat account also republished an interview with Deng Yu, conducted by the Beijing International Center for Mathematical Research (BICMR), but internet users quickly noticed that PKU’s version of the interview had been selectively edited, with numerous alterations and a question about overseas study deleted entirely. CDT Chinese editors compiled a side-by-side comparison of the original interview and PKU’s selectively edited text.
Congratulatory messages projected onto Peking University’s famed Boya Pagoda read: “Congratulations to Wang Hong and Deng Yu!” and “Congratulations to Chinese mathematics!”
Perhaps the most viral topic was a video interview in which Wang confided that she “felt a little discouraged” during her time at Peking University. The English word “discouraged” soon became a trending hashtag on Weibo, but was later censored, although some related content referencing Wang’s use of “discouraged” could still be viewed. Many Chinese social media users shared their own experiences of feeling thwarted by what they described as an overly hierarchical and inflexible academic system, and debated whether the two Fields Medal winners would have chalked up the same achievements had they remained in China. Wang’s comment clearly resonated with many Chinese netizens, and CDT has archived several articles on the subject. A piece from WeChat account Her Narrative, “Thank You, Wang Hong, for Saying the Word ‘Discouraged,’” describes Wang’s early frustrations and circuitous academic path, highlights the importance of her graduate studies in France and the U.S. and finding her “true mentors,” and encourages readers to live life at their own pace and not to lose confidence. In “Why We All Understood What Wang Hong Meant by ‘Discouraged,’” from WeChat account Plucking a Bashful Moon, the author discusses growing up in China and having their shortcomings frequently pointed out by teachers and parents, and contrasts this with what they view as a more supportive and positive culture of encouragement in Italy, where the author has spent some time.
In a video interview, Fields Medalist Wang Hong described her time studying Earth Sciences at Peking University, “I felt a little discouraged.”
In connection with this discussion of “educational trauma,” some suggested using the term “school of origin” (原生学校, yuánshēng xuéxiào) to refer to PKU’s complex relationship with alumni such as Wang and Deng. “School of origin” derives from "family of origin" (原生家庭, yuánshēng jiātíng), a term used in psychology to refer to the family—and family trauma—one was born into. One Chinese-language comment on Threads that received over 5,000 likes said that in the case of Wang and Deng, “PKU has played the role of their ‘school of origin.’” Other users agreed, with one humorously complaining, “Look at my family of origin, school of origin, and country of origin … I’m totally screwed.”
In an archived piece from WeChat account History Rhymes, “Wang Hong and Deng Yu Won the Fields Medal, But How Much Credit Does Peking University Really Deserve?” current affairs blogger Xu Peng discusses this question in light of the academic histories of the two mathematicians, both of whom attended PKU but whose advanced degrees and subsequent academic achievements were earned abroad. In one widely-shared quote, Xu likens their relationship with their Chinese alma mater to that between Yang Guo, the fictional protagonist of Jin Yong’s wuxia novel “The Return of the Condor Heroes,” and the Quanzhen martial arts sect. In Xu’s example, the Quanzhen Sect served as Yang Guo’s “school of origin,” the place where he spent an unhappy and unproductive tutelage under a master who resented him. A short excerpt from Xu’s article follows:
The recent news that two Chinese mathematicians have won the Fields Medal has sparked a frenzy online and given our nation’s “triumphalists” yet another reason to cheer.
Many say that the awards won by Wang Hong and Deng Yu, both Chinese, are a milestone for China. Chinese media has also emphasized that Wang Hong and Deng Yu are both alumni of Peking University.
[…] But how much did their success really have to do with Peking University? There’s certainly some connection there, but the university likely played a minor role.
You could call it the first step on their mathematical path. Without that first step, they might not have reached the pinnacle of their profession.
It feels a bit like Yang Guo’s relationship with the Quanzhen Sect.
If they hadn’t gone abroad, and had conducted their mathematical research in China, would they still have won the Fields Medal?
[…] They are the first two Chinese nationals to win that prize, and this goes to prove that Chinese people are capable of such an achievement.
But as the saying goes: "Orange trees grown south of the River Huai yield sweet fruit, while those north of the river bear bitter fruit.” Even the best seedlings require good soil if they’re to produce a bountiful harvest. [Chinese]



