Recent weeks have seen extreme weather across central and southern China, particularly in Guangxi, where a dam breach led to at least 26 deaths. These events sparked widespread online discussion about accountability for human failings that exacerbated the damage; lionization of rescue efforts as a distraction from those failings; official euphemisms such as "a gap appeared" for the dam breach; the role of domestic media; and reflexive hostility to foreign reporting. Much of this has been censored; some of it has been archived and translated by CDT.

In the midst of this, last week brought the fifth anniversary of the deadly 2021 floods in Zhengzhou, Henan. A leaked media directive showed the typical playbook: "Regarding the heavy rain striking Henan and other places, shift the focus of reporting toward post-disaster recovery […] do not publish unauthorized images showing dead bodies, take an exaggeratedly sorrowful tone, or hype or draw connections to past events." In early 2022, China’s State Council released the results of an investigation that sharply criticized local authorities, in part for obscuring the death toll, but when the first anniversary arrived months later, censorship and opacity reigned again.

Many of the themes in translated commentary on the 2021 floods have resurfaced this year. As commentator Xiang Dongliang wrote in a previously translated post on the current floods: "All of this ought to be common sense by now. But here we are in 2026, and we’re having to reiterate it yet again, which is truly lamentable."

The two censored posts translated below display a similar longing for accountability and transparency, and reflect upon memory and forgetting in that environment. As writer Huang Zhijie, under the pen name "Youyou Luming," concludes in the first post: "Forgetting often means that an essentially identical man-made disaster occurs again; that an accident investigation report that came close to the truth becomes just a blank piece of paper."

Today is July 20, 2026.

This marks the fifth anniversary of the July 20, 2021 ("720") Zhengzhou floods.

To be honest, I really don’t know what to say.

I had actually forgotten all about it.

The first thing I remembered was that "Raincoat Dad," whose real name is still unknown.

That year on July 27, the seventh day after the deaths, a man sat quietly outside Shakoulu station on Line 5 of the Zhengzhou Metro. He wore a dark blue raincoat, black sunglasses, and a blue facemask with an opening cut at the mouth. Next to him, propped against his parked bicycle, was a piece of cardboard reading: "Niuniu, Daddy still wants to bring you home."

He never spoke.

The father.

[…] According to a subsequent police investigation, the man was a section chief at a Zhengzhou work unit, and was the father of Zhang __yue, one of the people who died on that subway line. The man’s younger sister said that he was wearing that raincoat because he had been wearing it when he said goodbye to his daughter that morning; and the sunglasses, because his daughter had given them to him. His mask had an opening because he didn’t want the condensation to fog up his glasses. He had always used that bicycle to take his daughter home.

"Niuniu" was his special pet name for his daughter. Even though she was already 27 and married with a two-year-old of her own, in her father’s eyes, she would always be his little girl. "My brother always regretted not having taught her to swim, and blamed himself for not finding out about the subway flooding in time. He always wondered whether, if he could turn back time, there might have been something he could have done to change what happened."

[…] A total of 398 people died during the “720 incident.” Of these deaths, 139 were concealed at the township, county, or city levels. According to the State Council’s later investigation, many of the flooding deaths should never have happened, particularly the incident on Line 5 of the Zhengzhou Metro (in which 953 people were trapped, and 14 died) and in the northern tunnel of Zhengzhou’s Jingguang expressway (in which 247 vehicles were submerged, and six people died).

Raincoat Dad’s daughter was among those who died.

The investigation report said that the disaster was "generally natural, with specific human failings," and that there were six major issues with the relevant departments:

  1. Response deployment was neither timely nor sufficient;
  2. Emergency response lagged badly;
  3. Emergency measures were imprecise and ineffective;
  4. Unified command was lacking at key moments;
  5. Organization and mobilization were insufficient;
  6. Reported numbers of those dead and missing were delayed and concealed.

At one point afterwards, chrysanthemums left by Zhengzhou residents or sent from netizens from all over the country blanketed the ground far around the subway entrance, and the messages on the cards among them were even more moving. Despite efforts by some to obstruct this, the urge to commemorate the victims was irrepressible.

[…] One card read: "You passed through this world. We remember your bravery!"

A drone photo of yellow bouquets spread out in front of the subway station. Reporters from Caixin and Southern Metropolis Daily were arrested for taking drone images of the impromptu memorial.

Why is it that people are willing to persist, to brave the consequences, in order to express their grief and commemorate the ordinary victims of disaster?

I think it’s because those ordinary office workers, those ordinary daughters, are so much like ourselves. Their fates struck without warning, as could happen to any ordinary person.

People who had been trapped on the subway recalled their fellow passengers, after many hours of confinement, beginning to show signs of oxygen deprivation—shaking, gasping for breath, and retching—while others fainted or suffocated.

Some people online said that just reading these accounts and watching the videos was enough to give them shortness of breath, headaches, or insomnia. For some, it evoked the anxieties of the pandemic years.

When people see the minutiae of these ordinary victims’ lives, both before and after their passing, their great sorrow becomes a form of memory.

I’m conflicted.

On one hand, my general habit is to dig into every detail of a major disaster as exhaustively as possible, trying to remember. On the other, I also tend to forget it all as completely as possible.

Because as far as I’m concerned, this kind of sorrowful memory is an enormous burden. I have to constantly purge it if I’m to return to a normal emotional state.

If the “post-disaster reconstruction” is this hard for me, an outsider, how must it feel for people from Zhengzhou?

As an old media veteran, I seem to know a lot—much more than ordinary people. But I also seem to know very little, to the extent that some great events I witnessed firsthand seem to have left little trace in my memory.

Sometimes forgetting is as terrible as the disaster itself.

Forgetting often means that an essentially identical man-made disaster occurs again; that an accident investigation report that came close to the truth becomes just a blank piece of paper; that the bicycle that carried a child, a father’s raincoat, the sunglasses his daughter gave him … it means that all these details will come into our view once more.

May we who have lived through disaster avoid further disaster; and, having grasped the human causes of catastrophe, may we avoid man-made catastrophe in future.

Youyou Luming, July 20, 2026 [Chinese]

The second post is by Henan-born, Chengdu-based writer Zhang Feng, the owner of a celebrated independent bookstore that narrowly escaped closure last year. Zhang noted that most of the commemorative posts he had seen made no demands for accountability, but were deleted anyway.

In the bookstore today, I heard a pair of young women sighing: "I can’t believe it’s been five years since the Zhengzhou floods."

I was amazed—I hadn’t expected that young folks in Chengdu would still remember it. "What do you remember of it?" I asked them.

"There was a father waiting for his daughter at the subway station, just waiting, for days and days."

I paid close attention to the Zhengzhou floods at the time, and wrote two pieces about them, thinking that if the police in my hometown wanted to come and arrest me for it, then let them. But I don’t even remember that detail.

Those two young women probably got their information through different channels, building their own image of the "Zhengzhou floods."

I’ve seen a lot of videos and articles commemorating the Zhengzhou floods in the last couple of days. There were a lot of comments relating details of that time, mostly expressions of gratitude or calls to remember the city’s suffering. I saw almost no abuse, or demands for accountability.

Sadly, most of those videos and posts were deleted. As someone from Henan, I’m sorry to see this.

Zhengzhou is a large city that’s developed a lot over the past 20 years. I remember that when I left for university in 1997, Zhengzhou hardly merited a mention among China’s cities, but now, in the age of high-speed rail and mobile internet, it’s seen as a hub.

But it’s not a city whose spirit will stir your soul.

I know there’s a pretty good song about it, "Memory About Zhengzhou," a nice tune [embedded below; by banned folk singer Li Zhi]. Chengdu seized on the Zhao Lei song that’s named for it; when I was in Flushing, New York, and heard someone singing "Chengdu" in the street, I couldn’t help but get misty-eyed.

But I’ve seen no sign of Zhengzhou trying to capitalize on its own song that way.

It’s a similar story with commemoration of the floods. Merciless floodwaters brought disaster, but part of it was man-made, or revealed shortcomings in the city’s construction, and these caused further misfortune. But if a city were to establish a "Flood Memorial Hall" to tell the story of the disaster and remind visitors of its lessons, that would be entirely to its credit.

I even have an idea for such a memorial hall. It could be located in a subway station, and use advanced equipment to create a kind of "drowning experience." The names of the victims could be listed, so we would never forget them. Commemorative items could be displayed; the deeds of "heroic citizens" could be recorded.

In any case, a city ultimately belongs to its people. Becoming its "citizen" is not just a matter of buying a house or possessing a household registration; it also involves learning the city’s traditions and culture, and the hardships she has suffered. The people of a place have shared feelings and shared sorrows, which can become ingrained as a sort of "local dialect."

It’s like Chengdu in 2008. If you were here [during the Wenchuan earthquake] in 2008; if you saw or heard about family and friends who died; if you grieved and were heartbroken, but also reached out your hands to others, then how could you not love her?

In that sense, I’m proud of Zhengzhou. The simple fact that so many people have not forgotten gives you a little more confidence. [Chinese]