Microblogging platform Weibo is cracking down on speech about crackdowns on speech. In a weekly “safety” digest published to an official Weibo administrators’ account, the platform announced that it had suspended over 10 accounts for “hyping the censorship of other accounts.” The owners of the accounts were issued suspensions (禁言, jìnyán) for posting about, or “hyping,” suspensions imposed on other accounts. Such suspensions are often imposed for violating Weibo platform rules and regulations, or transgressing Weibo’s numerous but unwritten political taboos.
Below is a screenshot of the Weibo safety digest, followed by an English translation of the digest content. It lists a number of accounts (anonymized in the original Chinese post via the use of asterisks) that have been suspended for reasons including “hyping the censorship of other accounts,” “repeatedly posting negative economic news,” or “flooding Weibo with harmful foreign information”:
2024, Volume 29
Weekly Safety Tips
Example Cases
@ling**xing, @wo***fu, @M******bi, @jiang****zi, @qun*****jia, @pan**tan, @shen**jing, @shi**yang, @lin*xiang, @bei***ren, and other “Big V” accounts have been suspended for hyping the censorship of other accounts, thus seeding illegal discourse that defamed and harmed the national image.
“Big V” accounts @li****tian and @yuan**xin attacked and mocked Chinese government institutions and systems. Accounts @jie******lüe, @gu*****zhe, and @gu***ge repeatedly posted negative economic news and have been suspended for violating platform rules and regulations. The account @yubeixiaotiejiang has been banned for continuously flooding [Weibo] with harmful foreign information.
Summary and Warning
A reminder to all creators: in order to avoid fueling irrational suspicion, or even harmful comments, please do not hype the censorship of other accounts. Weibo will continue to provide creators with creative safety tips and content section management tools to help foster safe creating.
Our delegation to the Paris Olympics earned China’s best-ever showing at an overseas Olympic Games. While we congratulate the athletes, we must also maintain a rational attitude towards stars and reject bashing [athletes and other fans]. We look forward to continued success at future competitions! [Chinese]
The news inspired outrage—and jokes—on Weibo. One asked in jest, “Can we call it ‘twice-cooked censorship’ when an account gets censored for hyping the censorship of accounts suspended for hyping the censorship of other accounts?” (The joke is a reference to “twice-cooked pork,” a popular Sichuan dish.) Many of the Weibo user reactions compiled by CDT were expressions of dismay:
野猫羔 :Fuck! Hyping the censorship of other accounts will also trigger censorship… 😓
Sonic969 :Hilarious: censored for discussing censorship
刺猬头_Official : You can’t say why they were censored, and you definitely can’t say why you can’t say why.
C0ingwinter :From now on users will engage in endless self-censorship.
幻想移动: What are the parameters for deciding if someone is “hyping the censorship of other accounts”?
重生第三次 :The current speech environment is just terrific.
武烈山 :Dude, now it’s “hyping”—they’re always coming up with new words like that. Next they’ll be censoring anyone who “hypes” the “censorship hypers.” [Chinese]
In the comment section of the original Weibo post announcing the suspensions, buried beneath a sea of seemingly astroturfed supportive comments, one Weibo user sarcastically praised free speech in China by quoting past pronouncements from Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MoFA) spokespeople:
Adrian_Zhang_bj: 1.4 billion people all have the right to express their opinions.
(Top photo: MoFA spokesperson Hua Chunying and caption) “Hua Chunying: ‘There are about 1.4 billion people in China, each with his or her own mind, and each entitled to the freedom to voice his or her views and thoughts online.'”
(Bottom photo: former MoFA spokesman Zhao Lijian and caption) “Foreign Ministry: ‘In China, there are no speech crimes.'” [Chinese]
Now, you can combat internet censorship in a new way: by toggling the switch below while browsing China Digital Times, you can provide a secure "bridge" for people who want to freely access information. This open-source project is powered by Lantern, know more about this project.
CDT is a non-profit media site, and we need your support. Your contribution will help us provide more translations, breaking news, and other content you love.